Articles

Was the Catholic Church’s response to alleged ‘vote chori' adequate?

Opinion | Articles | John Dayal |

It must be on record that the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of India (CBCI) has condemned the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in the country by the Election Commission of India, saying, “Disenfranchisement must never become the ‘new normal.’"

Not far behind, the All India Catholic Union (AICU) called out the police brutality against young “Gen Z” women and men protestors against the SIR, and demanded the immediate release of all detained demonstrators and an independent inquiry into police actions.

The larger question of whether Christians have been as involved as they should be in the people’s struggle for free and fair elections is embarrassing to the community. It exposes its own understanding of how far it can afford to go in solidarity with civil society and ordinary citizens without exposing itself to the wrath of a vindictive and majoritarian government and polity.

The theological mandate is unambiguous, in the minds of civil society itself; an honest assessment is that Christians have been gravely, culpably absent when the chips were down, especially during the 12 years of rule by Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

The struggle against SIR, in which approximately 130 million names were deleted from voter lists, clearly shows that while titular community agencies put the protest on record with clarity, the organized, sustained lay mobilization that the moment demands remains underdeveloped.

The Catholic Church does not regard political participation as an optional extracurricular for the especially zealous — like the three octogenarians, Jesuit Cedric Prakash of Gujarat, Delhi’s retired Vicar General Father Susai Sebastian, and the late Jesuit Stan Swami of Jharkhand, who died a prisoner of the state — and Sister Maria Nirmalini, the Apostolic Superior of the Apostolic Carmel Congregation.

The 2002 “Doctrinal Note on Some Questions Regarding the Participation of Catholics in Political Life” insists that the lay faithful are never to relinquish their participation in public life, and that democracy could not be productive without their active, responsible and generous involvement.

Latin American bishops have repeatedly stressed that the vote is not a merely individual act but part of a broader commitment to society, one that continues after election day through the monitoring of elected officials.

The United States bishops have similarly reminded Catholics that participation in public life — including voting — is both a right and a responsibility, and that discouragement in the face of political division is not a Christian virtue. Christians are expected not merely to vote but to defend the integrity of the electoral process itself.

Pope Leo cast his vote — like a good US citizen while also being the sovereign of the Holy See.

Where Christians, particularly Catholics, are in large numbers, the church can tilt the balance in favor of democracy, and often against dictatorships and tyrannical rulers.

There is a little-known, in India at least, study by political scientist Dina Lotfy of 59 national Catholic churches between the 1990s and 2023 that found only 32 percent resisted electoral manipulation, while 34 percent confined themselves to calls for peace, and another 34 percent took no stance at all.

They reflect a broader pattern in which churches calculate that their institutional survival, or their access to patronage, is better served by silence than by confrontation. Churches are contingent, rather than inherent, activists for liberal democracy; their default posture, especially when their own privileges are secure, is accommodation rather than resistance.

It is against this global backdrop of heroic fidelity and shameful evasion that critics review the Church response to the Indian SIR, conducted in phases from 2025 into 2026, which has produced one of the more sustained civic mobilizations of recent years.

Youth-led groups under the banner of the Cockroach Janata Party (CJP), the INDIA bloc of opposition parties, Left student organizations, and civil society networks have organized marches, sit-ins, and public hearings in Delhi, Bengaluru, Mumbai, Hyderabad, and other cities.

Their demands have included the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, the rollback of voter deletions, restoration of pre-revision rolls, and reform of the law governing the appointment of election commissioners. 

Alternate media coverage — the pro-Modi “Godi” or lapdog media did not mostly report it — documented both the scale of the protests and the police responses, including mass detentions, prohibitory orders, and restrictions even on the tiny “designated protest sites” such as Jantar Mantar near Parliament Street in New Delhi.

India’s Christians number roughly 2.3 percent of its more than 1.4 billion people, and they are by long historical tradition and by the social teaching of the Catholic Church, committed to the dignity of the person, the common good, and the rights that flow from the constitution. 

The right to vote is the foundational expression of equal citizenship, and when that right is placed in doubt through mass administrative exclusion, silence is not neutrality, as the saying goes.

The Conference of Religious India, representing more than 115,000 men and women religious, declared that they could not be “silent spectators,” that they had a responsibility “to bear witness to the person and message of Jesus by standing up for truth and justice.” It explicitly called on religious and their collaborators to join the national campaigns.

Individual Christians have publicly linked the mobilization to the preservation of India’s constitutional soul, describing it as a journey to preserve the soul of India.

Local initiatives have also appeared: Cochin Diocese organized a post-SIR campaign of household visits to identify those left off the rolls; Cardinal Anthony Poola of Hyderabad, who also chairs the CBCI, issued a circular treating the revision as both pastoral and civic duty and directing parishes to appoint volunteers; interfaith groups in Telangana and Andhra Pradesh conducted awareness and train-the-trainer sessions.

The statements, though firm, have remained largely at the level of press releases and internal circulars, with little evidence of sustained, coordinated mobilization of the laity comparable to the energy visible among student organizations, farmer groups, or the youth-led CJP.

Parish-level engagement appears episodic — help desks here, circulars there — rather than systemic. National lay bodies such as the AICU have condemned repression but have not, on the public record, organized large-scale independent or joint actions that would place Christian presence visibly within the broader movement.

Coverage in Catholic media has reported the institutional statements faithfully, yet the volume of such reporting does not match the intensity of secular media attention to the scale of the deletions and the street protests.

Christians remain a small and geographically dispersed minority; they are acutely conscious of the risks of being labeled political.

Sixty years of anti-conversion legislation, now totally weaponized in a dozen states ruled by the pro-Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party and Karnataka governed by the secular Congress, and targeted hate and violence, have encouraged a posture of caution.

Many Church institutions depend on legal and administrative goodwill, including leases and favorable decisions by local municipalities and district collectors, that can be withdrawn.

The internal life of the Church, still marked by uneven lay empowerment more than 60 years after Vatican II, does not always produce the habits of civic co-responsibility that social teaching requires.

When formation remains primarily sacramental and catechetical, the translation of Gospel values into organized defense of the common good is left to the initiative of individuals and a few commissions, critics among the religious and laity.

It is obvious that involvement need not mean partisan alignment, and it could well have taken the form of parish-based documentation of deletions, legal-aid desks, interfaith monitoring of the revision process, public education on constitutional rights, and non-violent accompaniment of peaceful protests. 

It requires the same seriousness from bishops, religious and lay leaders that they show on other issues of justice, including the vexatious issue of proposed changes to the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, 1976, which governs the process by which non-governmental organizations, religious bodies and charities receive overseas funding.

The Christian establishment has gone to the Supreme Court and the Joint Parliamentary Committee, set up to conduct detailed examination and wider consultation to “help evolve a balanced statutory framework” for the country’s foreign funding law.

Christians, precisely because they are a minority whose own rights are frequently contested, have a particular interest in the integrity of these institutions. 

The alternative is a withdrawal that leaves the defense of the rights to others while the community continues to invoke the language of human dignity and the common good.

The salt risks losing its savor.

(The author is a Senior Journalist and right Activist. View expressed in the article are personal)

 

 

 

 

 

 



Leave a comment